(714) 403-7130

ATTENTION : Homeowners & Drivers

The Smartest Way to Save on Insurance.

We shop over 15 top-rated carriers to find you the perfect blend of coverage and price so you don’t have to.

Stop Letting One Insurance Company Dictate Your Price.

No cost. No obligation. 100% Local Service.

WE COMPARE RATES FROM THE NATION'S MOST TRUSTED CARRIERS

Auto-Owners

Liberty Mutual

Bear River Mutual

Selective

Progressive

Request Your Insurance Comparison Quote

Stop overpaying. Fill out the form below and let us shop 15+ top carriers for you.

Country

Everything You Need To Know About

Personal Insurance At A Glance

What is Personal Insurance?

Personal Insurance provides comprehensive protection for your home and vehicle, covering risks like accidents, natural disasters, theft, and liability. Secure your peace of mind and financial stability by choosing the right insurance that perfectly fits your needs.

Important Details

Insurance offers coverage to protect against unexpected events. Choose a policy that aligns with your lifestyle and budget to safeguard your most valuable assets and ensure your future is fully protected.

Why Choose an Independent Agent?


Most people don't realize there are two ways to buy insurance:

The "Captive" Way

You call a big brand (like the ones with the lizards or stadiums). The agent can only sell you that one company's product. If their rates go up? You’re stuck.

The "Independent" Way (Us)

We work for YOU, not the insurance company. We have access to the entire marketplace.

We Are Your Personal Shopper

We compare dozens of quotes at once

We Are Your Advocate

If you have a claim, we are on your side of the table, fighting for a fair payout.

We Are Lifetime Partners

At every renewal, we re-check the market. If your rate creeps up, we can switch carriers without you losing your agent.

READY TO GIVE US A TRY?

Lets Connect!

Get a free quote, compare insurance rates, and work with a trusted local, independent insurance expert. No obligation, no pressure, and a free policy review.

The Audit

Most homeowners are underinsured due to rising costs. We audit your policy to ensure you aren't paying for 'fluff' or missing protection.

The Match

We match your specific risk profile (credit, driving history, home age) with the carrier that has the biggest appetite for you.

The Bundle

We maximize multi-policy discounts by bundling Home, Auto, Toys, and Umbrella policies under one roof, often saving clients 15-20%.

MEET Your Cottonwood Insurance Agent

Zack McGonigle

Independent Cottonwood Insurance Agent

Insurance doesn’t have to be confusing, overpriced, or stressful—and that belief is what drives Zack McGonigle, a trusted independent insurance agent in Utah with Cottonwood Insurance.

Zack works with individuals, families, and businesses across Utah, including Salt Lake City, Provo, Lehi, Orem, Draper, Sandy, Ogden, Eagle Mountain, Alpine, Saratoga Springs, and St. George, helping them secure affordable, reliable insurance coverage that actually fits their lives and budgets.

Unlike captive agents who represent only one company, Zack is a local independent insurance agent who compares rates and coverage options from multiple top-rated insurance carriers. This allows him to deliver better protection, more competitive pricing, and policies tailored to each client’s unique needs, whether that’s auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, or commercial insurance.

What truly sets Zack apart is his education-first, transparent approach. He takes the time to explain coverage in plain language, identify potential gaps, and help clients make confident, informed decisions. From car insurance in Utah and homeowners insurance to business insurance, general liability, and workers’ compensation, Zack provides expert guidance with fast, responsive service.

Many clients come to Zack after experiencing insurance rate increases, switching providers, starting a new business, or simply wanting to compare insurance quotes in Utah. No matter the situation, he makes the process simple, clear, and stress-free, earning long-term trust and referrals throughout the state.

Known as a go-to Utah insurance broker for both personal and commercial insurance solutions, Zack is committed to working for his clients, not the insurance companies. For anyone searching for a local Utah insurance agent who delivers better coverage, better rates, and personalized service, Zack McGonigle is the trusted choice to protect your home, vehicles, business, and future.

Licensed in 50 States

Licensed with Property & Casualty, Life & Health

11+ Years of experience

TESTIMONIALS

What others are saying

"Loved everything so far"

"I thought I had a great rate until Zack McGonigle looked at my policy. Not only did I save $600 a year, but I found out my old policy wouldn't have covered my roof."

— Sarah J., Lehi, UT

"My life changed forever"

"Finally, an agent who actually answers the phone. I love that I can text them questions and get real answers, not a call center robot."

— Mike T., Salt Lake City

"Highly recommend"

"Been working with Zack for years! He is fantastic and recommend them to anyone who has insurance needs."

— Julia Ray., Oregon

Request Your Comparison Quote

Stop overpaying. Fill out the form below and let us shop 15+ top carriers for you.

Country

Better Coverage, Lower Rates. See How Much You Could Save.

Better Coverage, Lower Rates. See How Much You Could Save.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does it cost extra to use an Independent Agent?

A: Absolutely not. We are paid a commission by the insurance carrier you choose. Your rate is exactly the same (often lower due to our expertise) as if you went direct.

Q: Will you spam me with calls?

A: No. We hate spam too. We will reach out to gather any missing details and present your quote options. We treat you the way we want to be treated.

Q: How long does a quote take?

A: Because we shop multiple carriers to find the absolute best fit, please allow us 24 hours to build your comprehensive proposal.

Zack McGonigle
Cottonwood Insurance Agent

2028 E Fort Union Blvd, Unit 100

Cottonwood Heights, UT 84121

(714) 403-7130

Image

Innovation

Fresh, creative solutions.

Image

Integrity

Honesty and transparency.

Excellence

Excellence

Top-notch services.

FOLLOW US

COMPANY

CUSTOMER CARE

LEGAL

Copyright 2026. Zack McGonigle's Account. All Rights Reserved.

Zack McGonigle is an employee of Cottonwood Insurance Inc. to provide expert customer service and increased carrier access.